If anyone tells you these two platforms are similar, that’s far from the truth.
Yes, there is some video advertising you can do on Google’s platform but that’s just Youtube Ads so we’ll make a video and article on that in the future. . .
For now there is multiple major differences in the way the two platforms work
- Different payment structure (CPM vs CPC)
- Different way to market
- Different methodology behind the actual advertising
- Different focus
- Different ways of demand capture
Let’s dive in.
First, the payment structure is different
By that I mean on Meta you’ll pay your CPMs (Aka $x per 1000 impressions)
Meaning you pay per views and you have to get good at turning views into leads
To be clear this is still different from doing organic content and adding CTA’s, these have data backed targeting to be clear and regular content doesn’t.
Now on Google you’ll have to pay for each click, your CPC. On here you’ve got to get good at turning clicks into leads and if you don’t have someone skilled in making good high converting landing pages, you’ll light money on fire faster than you’ll waste your money on Google ads.
Second, The Format
One you have to record an ad or put together an static creative (still image) the other you put together a landing page and put in the keywords you want to show up for and put in headlines
Both take a different amount of camera shyness.
Third, The Methodology
The harsh truth is, Google Ads takes some time and you need a lot of skin in the game.
And by time I mean at least 90 days to see the baseline of results if you’re even spending enough.
And by skin in the game I mean for home service businesses at least $100-$200 per day, if you have less. Go to Meta Ads
Meta ads on the other hand is fast results, like within a week leads fast (If you’re spending above $50 per day)
Meta ads is also a lot lower spend BUT, there is some nuances
In Meta Ads you can get away with a low spend because let’s say there is a big shot in the area doing $1000/d meta ads then as soon as the customer clicks and submits on their ad, a bunch more roofers / remodelers / window guys / whatever you are start getting sent to them and if they are already looking for 3 quotes, they might just click on you too as you come next
Now on Google ads you’ve got a different story,
On Google Ads you need a high spend and aggressive keyword strategies since if the big shots spending $1000/d on google get the click, the customer tends to not navigate around anymore to find another.
They usually go from Google ad to google maps and start calling around or whatever they end up doing.
On Meta you can at least benefit from them, on Google you’ll get crushed by them.
So summary there, Google Ads is a high spending long game that has high quality consistent results and Meta Ads is a everyone game that is fast paced, with mid to high quality results (Depending on your qualification process) that can get consistent results if you actually have good media buying and creatives.
Fourth, Different Focuses
When running Meta Ads you’ve got to be focused on the offer. Google, not so much.
Now you can get a better quality of lead and more leads if you have a good offer but truth is, it matters wayy more on Meta.
You might be able to get away with a “Free Quote” offer on Google Ads but in Meta, no way.
You’d be lucky if someone even submitted it on accident.
Just kidding it isn’t that bad but it’s so important to have a good offer in Meta Ads I made a whole video about it – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vDyR0MIQCDQ&t=7s
Lastly, Different Demand Generation
Some forget about this part when picking the platform and deciding which one is best for them but Meta Ads is more Demand Generation.
Yes there is some capture in people who are currently interested but for the most part you’re informing a homeowner about a new program, new financing plan, etc. that brings new people into the top of funnel.
Now Google Ads on the other hand is Demand Capture,
Think Meta is more like running around with a net catching butterflies while Google Ads is more like standing by the places the butterflies go and catching them there.
Of course, everyone wants to stand where they’ll go since it’s easiest but it’ll also be the most crowded and competitive for a butterfly since for most its least effort.
So as the example states, Google Ads is more like waiting around letting the homeowners look up “Roof Replacement Company Near Me” “HVAC Installer Near Me” and just being the person who shows up ready for the click.
How to know which one is for you
There’s many situations you might be in but both aren’t a one size fits all deal.
On one hand if you’ve got a Google ads budget above $10k/m, are willing to eat some cash in the short term to build a consistent and highly qualified inbound lead source, then Google Ads is recommended.
On the other hand if you’ve got any budget, have the will to do the effort, and have a way to make a good offer (Financing), then Meta Ads will be for you.
They are both different beasts to tame since they both have different nuances as to how you should media buy, how you should setup landing pages, and how you should spend so it’s up to you to choose.
Or I would recommend some expert guidance from an agency on what platform you should pick and see if they might be a good fit to run your ads, Book A Discovery Call Here
Article By
Karel Stoy is the Founder & CEO at Stoymedia. Karel has over 1.5 years in the marketing agency space and learned everything he knows from running ads for clients, running a full blown marketing agency, and spending countless amounts of dollars on books & resources.
Karel Stoy is the Founder & CEO at Stoymedia. Karel has over 1.5 years in the marketing agency space and learned everything he knows from running ads for clients, running a full blown marketing agency, and spending countless amounts of dollars on books & resources.
Similar Blogs
Let’s Talk About Your Marketing.